AGP Picks
View all

AI search tools often pick different roofers than Google Maps, study finds

Oct. 30, 2026
AI search tools often pick different roofers than Google Maps, study finds
By AI, Created 11:39 UTC, Oct 30, 2026, AGP -

An Overtake Marketing study of 20 U.S. cities found that AI tools named 199 rated roofers, but 133 of them — about two in three — sat outside each city's Google Maps top 10. The findings suggest roofing companies may need to monitor visibility in AI answers as well as in traditional local search.

Why it matters: - AI search is becoming a real local-recommendation channel for homeowners looking for roofers. - A roofing company can rank well in Google Maps and still miss the answer shown by ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini or Google AI Overviews. - The study suggests review volume, source citations and tool-specific visibility may now shape which contractors get shortlisted first.

What happened: - Overtake Marketing studied local roofer results across 20 U.S. cities. - Researchers sent 80 queries to four AI tools on Oct. 15 and Oct. 16, 2026. - The team collected 67 AI-generated answers and identified 199 rated roofers in those answers. - Of those 199 roofers, 133 were outside their city's Google Maps top 10. - AI Overviews appeared in 7 of the 20 cities.

The details: - The AI answers named 225 city-and-business pairs in total. - Researchers merged 7 duplicate name variants and set aside 19 pairs with no single rated listing. - The baseline comparison used the top 10 Google Maps results for “roofer in” each city, for 200 total listings. - The median roofer named by AI had 289 Google reviews, compared with 242 for the Google Maps top 10. - About 85% of AI-picked roofers had 100 or more reviews, versus 80% of the Maps top 10. - About 57% of AI-picked roofers had 250 or more reviews, versus 49% of the Maps top 10. - Roofers named by two or more tools had a median of 484 reviews, more than double the roughly 228 reviews for roofers named by only one tool. - Both groups shared a median star rating of 4.9. - In the Maps top 10, 89% of roofers had ratings of 4.8 or above, compared with 83% of AI picks. - The four AI tools named 218 distinct roofing companies across the 20 cities. - The median was about 10 companies named per city. - Two or more tools named 70 companies in the same city, or about 32%. - Three or more tools named 16 companies. - Only two companies appeared on all four tool lists. - Four-tool agreement was possible only in the 7 cities where Google showed an AI Overview. - Of the 67 answers, 32 cited at least one review or directory site such as Yelp, Google, BBB, Angi or Thumbtack. - Perplexity cited those sources in 18 of its 20 answers, and AI Overviews did so in 6 of 7. - ChatGPT cited a review or directory site in 1 of 20 answers, and Gemini did so in 2 of 20. - Nearly all answers mentioned licensing or insurance. - About nine in 10 answers raised warranties. - More than half referred to manufacturer certifications. - The study did not rank roofers by quality and did not attempt to explain why any tool named any company. - The figures reflect one sample taken over two days and are not permanent rankings. - The company said the full answers and method notes are available on request, along with the business list and Google Maps baseline. - Sam Newland, CEO of Overtake Marketing, said AI tools in the study tended to name roofers with long review histories and many outside the Google Maps top 10.

Between the lines: - AI answers appear to behave like a second local shortlist, not a simple mirror of the map pack. - Review count seems to matter more than star rating in this sample. - Agreement across tools was limited, which means visibility can change depending on which AI product a homeowner opens. - The cited sources suggest AI systems may lean on directories and review platforms when assembling local recommendations.

What's next: - Overtake says roofing companies should check how each AI tool describes them and which competitors appear beside them. - The company recommends asking the same homeowner-style questions in ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini and Google AI Overviews, then comparing the results with local map rankings. - Roofers can use the exercise to spot outdated directory listings, missing credentials, weak review profiles or service descriptions that do not match what AI tools surface. - Overtake also advises repeating the check a few weeks later because AI answers can shift over time. - The company points operators to consistent business information across a Google Business Profile, website and the directories AI tools cite.

The bottom line: - For roofing companies, Google Maps is no longer the only local ranking that matters. AI answers are now part of the shortlist, and many of those picks fall outside the traditional top 10.

Disclaimer: This article was produced by AGP Wire with the assistance of artificial intelligence based on original source content and has been refined to improve clarity, structure, and readability. This content is provided on an “as is” basis. While care has been taken in its preparation, it may contain inaccuracies or omissions, and readers should consult the original source and independently verify key information where appropriate. This content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, financial, investment, or other professional advice.

Sign up for:

American Consumer Products Digest

The daily local news briefing you can trust. Every day. Subscribe now.

By signing up, you agree to our Terms & Conditions.

Share this page:

Advanced Search Options

Search for:

Search scope:

Type:

Search in:

Date range:

The last

Sort by:

Sign up for:

American Consumer Products Digest

The daily local news briefing you can trust. Every day. Subscribe now.

By signing up, you agree to our Terms & Conditions.