AGP Picks
View all

Survey finds major information gaps in credit counseling

Oct. 26, 2026
By AI, Created 16:01 UTC, Oct 26, 2026, AGP -

New Harris Poll data released by Debt Disclosure Project suggests most consumers who meet with credit counselors do not get the full picture on debt management plans, costs, or alternatives. The findings also show many enrollees face setbacks, extra fees, and unexpected outcomes during or after a plan.

Why it matters: - Credit counseling is often the first stop for people trying to deal with unsecured debt, so missing information can shape a major financial decision. - The survey suggests consumers may enter debt management plans without understanding total costs, credit impacts, or other options that could be cheaper or more flexible. - The findings also point to real-world fallout after enrollment, including collections, lawsuits, and added debt.

What happened: - Debt Disclosure Project released an analysis of survey data on how consumers experience credit counseling and debt management plans. - The Harris Poll surveyed 1,504 U.S. adults from Aug. 28-31, 2026. - Respondents were currently enrolled in, previously enrolled in, or had seriously considered a debt management plan in the past five years. - The analysis found that 91% of consumers who spoke with a credit counselor wanted better information on at least one debt management plan topic. - Only 6% recalled hearing about all four main unsecured-debt options: a debt management plan, debt settlement, a debt consolidation loan and bankruptcy. - 77% of current and former debt management plan enrollees experienced at least one listed financial setback during or after the plan.

The details: - Consumers most often wanted clearer information on future credit impact, total cost and plan length. - 36% wanted better information on how a debt management plan could affect future credit access. - 34% wanted better information on total cost, including all fees. - 34% wanted better information on how long the plan would take to complete. - 27% wanted to know how the agency earns revenue and whether that affects the options presented. - 27% wanted to know whether the proposed outcome was guaranteed or only an estimate. - 23% wanted to know about other options that may have been more affordable. - 52% recalled hearing about no more than one of the four main debt options. - 81% did not recall bankruptcy being discussed. - 58% did not recall a debt consolidation loan being discussed. - 52% did not recall debt settlement being discussed. - Among consumers with $25,000 or more in unsecured debt, only 11% recalled hearing about all four options. - Among households earning under $50,000, 66% recalled hearing about no more than one option, compared with 50% in households earning $100,000 or more. - 21% were not told about creditor-paid “fair share” payments before enrolling or considering enrollment. - 13% were never told about fair share payments at all. - Credit counseling agencies that administer debt management plans are commonly paid through setup fees, monthly fees and fair share payments from creditors. - Fair share payments can reach up to 15% of each consumer payment returned to the agency by creditors. - 25% of current and former enrollees saw a creditor revoke the reduced interest rate or remove them from the plan. - 41% had accounts sent to collections, were sued, or had wages garnished or bank accounts levied. - 15% were sued by a creditor or debt collector. - 36% took on new debt or fell behind on other bills to keep up with the debt management plan payment. - Among enrollees with $25,000 or more in unsecured debt, that figure rose to 42%. - 35% were dissatisfied with their plan or neither satisfied nor dissatisfied. - 23% said their debt management plan did not accomplish what they had hoped for. - 62% of former enrollees paid $1,000 or more in agency setup and monthly fees alone, not counting debt payments. - 23% paid $3,000 or more in those fees. - 21% paid fees but saw little or no reduction in what they owed. - 48% of former enrollees did not repay their balance in full. - 23% said the balance stayed about the same because payments mostly covered interest, or grew. - 20% of consumers who left a plan early or decided against one stopped paying some or all debts. - 21% borrowed from family or friends to manage debt. - 36% of those consumers stopped paying some debts, borrowed from family or friends, or both. - 25% turned to another formal option after leaving or declining a plan, including debt consolidation or balance transfer, debt settlement, or bankruptcy. - 54% kept making payments on their own.

Between the lines: - The findings raise questions about whether consumers are getting neutral guidance when one option may be more central to the agency’s revenue model than the alternatives. - The survey also suggests that fixed monthly payments and creditor-controlled interest concessions can make debt management plans fragile when income changes or hardship hits. - In practice, a plan marketed as a structured solution can still leave consumers exposed to collections, higher costs, or a return to the original debt terms.

What's next: - Debt Disclosure Project says consumers should ask about total cost, agency funding, all available options and what happens if a creditor stops participating or a payment is missed. - The organization says its public-records library is designed to help people compare what debt options really cost and how providers are funded. - The survey’s results may add pressure for clearer disclosure standards in credit counseling and debt management plan sales.

The bottom line: - The survey suggests many consumers enter debt counseling without the information they need and many debt management plan enrollees face costs or setbacks that can undercut the promised relief.

Disclaimer: This article was produced by AGP Wire with the assistance of artificial intelligence based on original source content and has been refined to improve clarity, structure, and readability. This content is provided on an “as is” basis. While care has been taken in its preparation, it may contain inaccuracies or omissions, and readers should consult the original source and independently verify key information where appropriate. This content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, financial, investment, or other professional advice.

Sign up for:

American Consumer Products Digest

The daily local news briefing you can trust. Every day. Subscribe now.

By signing up, you agree to our Terms & Conditions.

Share this page:

Advanced Search Options

Search for:

Search scope:

Type:

Search in:

Date range:

The last

Sort by:

Sign up for:

American Consumer Products Digest

The daily local news briefing you can trust. Every day. Subscribe now.

By signing up, you agree to our Terms & Conditions.